Skip to content

TO BE A JUDGE OR NOT ?

June 8, 2009

I always used to think that judging or to be a judge is so easy. You just have to sit on a separate chair away from all but center of attraction of everybody as everyone’s eyes are on you and like a king give your opinion.

But I soon came out of my delusions and I realized that Judging is totally a different experience. (And worth all the anxieties also)

Actually today I was asked to judge a painting competition and a Jodi No 1
couple) competition in some women’s social group

I was very apprehensive whether I will be able to do justice to the honour which has been bestowed on me?

Whether I will be able to do impartial judgement?

What if I miss out on some aspect?

What if the contestants are not happy with my judgement (everyone has their own preferences?)

What if someone criticizes my results?

I was sure it is going to be a nightmarish experience.

While I was musing over this, I was reminded of a Hindi classic story “PANCH PARMESHWAR BY MUNSHI PREMCHAND (I am sure no one from the present generation would have heard of him , just Google and see ). This is the famous story of two friends. Algu is the village chief and when it comes to do the justice, he doesn’t spare his best friend Jumman. Since Jumman did not get Algu’s favour, friends become foes. But at the end, when Jumman gets the chance to sit on the judgement seat, the realization comes now when the tables are turned and finally “Justice” wins. And then everyone says that the one who sits on the chair of judge cannot do injustice.

So taking inspiration from this story I went for the challenging job of judging. All the way to the venue I was continuously chanting that when you hold a position then certainly some responsibilities comes along with it which may defer you from being prejudiced towards any particular.

Luckily for me I knew none of the contestants but to adjudge fellow human beings, that too elderly ladies, all superseding one another it was a herculean task.

I was completely baffled as there was no clear cut out rules to select the best. I went on cutting and overwriting the marks, changing my opinions after the exit of each contestant. My writing pad was a complete mess. I was busy hiding it from the probing eyes of others (what will they think of me? such a messy lady)

(Hats off to all those judges who sit so confidently, calmly, patiently with smiles on their faces during all those beauty contests and reality shows)

Any ways to cut the whole thing short it finally got over and also came up with the same stereotyped speech that everyone was good and it was very difficult to select the best but I have tried my best etc etc.

Before the program I had vowed that I will never take this post again

BUT after the program I think that it was not all that bad experience and I may take another shot at it.

Advertisements
6 Comments leave one →
  1. Surya permalink
    June 8, 2009 6:06 pm

    nice… congrats for the best blog award… u surely were JUDGED the right way:)

  2. Milan permalink
    June 8, 2009 6:21 pm

    At times we are presented with challenges which at first we don't feel comfortable with but with the passage of time we realize the things we have learnt from the experience!

  3. ramya permalink
    June 9, 2009 2:06 am

    Well, I know Munshi Premchand. Read quiet a few stories of his. I remember my father bringing a small hindi book of stories of some good authors :-). didnt he write the famous Kabuliwala?
    Judging always a tough task, be it contestants or character of people 😀
    By the way, my name is Ramya and not Ramaya! 😀

  4. ZiLliOnBiG permalink
    June 9, 2009 5:37 am

    i have never been a judge anywhere, so cant comment on the experience, but in a way we all are judges, we judge people all the time, and many a times come to wrong conclusions. I like to believe that basically all human beings are good, some become bad due to the circumstances. i feel the moment we make judgement about people we would be a better human.

    i have read Premchand, we had his stories in CBSE hindi text books.i guesss he is quite popular. atleast for CBSE educated. cheers, nice writeup.I am sure you would have done justice to your judging. :)))

  5. The Panorama permalink
    June 9, 2009 12:41 pm

    It is indeed har to be a judge at a contest so I can understand your dilemma in selecting the best out of all the participants. However am sure you made the right choice. Enjoyed reading this post:)

  6. Mia permalink
    June 9, 2009 1:51 pm

    You didn't get my comment?? oh God, i posted it.. duno i cant see it here :0

    yes.. certainly judging is not dat easy but u've done it perfectly it seems..:)

    i liked these lines >>Before the program I had vowed that I will never take this post again

    BUT after the program I think that it was not all that bad experience and I may take another shot at it"

    i've felt several tyms d same for various things..
    Nice post..

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: